UBUDASHI
Library/Cartier/Paris, London and New York
Cartier

Paris, London and New York

Until the 1970s Cartier was three firms rather than one: the original house in Paris, and the houses in London (from 1902) and New York (from 1909), each run by a member of the family and each, to a real degree, independent. This page sets out how they were related, what the literature says of each, who supplied their cases and movements, which marks help to tell their watches apart, and what followed: the sale of the firms in the 1960s and 1970s, the affordable Must de Cartier watches, and the mechanical Collection Privée Cartier Paris of 1998 to 2008. The London house is far better recorded than New York.

How the three houses came to be

The firm began in Paris in 1847 and was passed from Louis-François Cartier to his son Alfred. Alfred's three sons divided the work between them: Louis stayed in Paris, Pierre went to New York and Jacques took London. London opened in 1902 at 4 New Burlington Street, in the year of Edward VII's coronation, and moved in 1909 to 175 and 176 New Bond Street, later taking in No. 177; New York opened in 1909 at 712 Fifth Avenue and moved to 653 Fifth Avenue in 1917. In 1906 Louis and Pierre formed a partnership styled Cartier Frères.

The houses were technically independent: each brother pursued his own contacts and chose his own products, while holding shares in the others' businesses, and in the days before easy telephone calls each had to act alone to some degree. The Paris house was where Louis designed. London and New York differed above all in who worked in their workshops: New York leaned on French craftsmen, while London trained English jewellers and watchmakers in the Cartier manner and let them work with more freedom.

Cartier Paris

Paris was the home of the firm's watch designs. Louis Cartier had a wristwatch made in 1904 for the aviator Alberto Santos-Dumont, which went on sale in 1911, and the Tonneau (1906), the Tortue (1912) and the Tank followed. The Tank was first drawn in 1917, shown in a first series in 1919 and, in its original form with straight side bars, is now called the Tank Normale to separate it from the Tank Louis Cartier, whose side bars are rounded. In the 1920s, by one account, the Paris workshop reworked the Tank into a range of shapes, among them the Cintrée, the Baignoire and the Tank à Guichets. Other accounts date the first oval Baignoire design to 1912 and its production to the late 1950s, not to the 1920s.

Production was small: between 1919 and 1960 the Paris house made 1,803 Tanks, fewer than forty-four a year. The stylised Roman numerals devised by Louis Cartier, with serifs and a railway (chemin de fer) minute track, are those of the original Paris Tank Cintrée, and were later reworked in London.

  • serifed Roman numerals with a railway minute track

Cartier London

London is the best documented of the three. Until the 1960s it sold watches made in Paris and Switzerland. By the 1960s the house was run by Jacques's son Jean-Jacques (the date of the handover is disputed), who added watchmakers to a house that already had goldsmiths and other craftsmen under one roof, so that it could design, make, assemble and sell in one city. The literature dates the start of London's own watch production variously (see Where accounts differ), but most of it falls between 1966 and 1974, with the Crash launched in 1967. London's own designs include the Baignoire Allongée, the Pebble and the Crash, and it made its own version of the Tank Asymétrique, a Paris design of 1936.

The Baignoire Allongée is dated to 1958 by one account and is recorded as a London model from the late 1960s by another. London Baignoires of about 1964 to 1974 are ovals from about 25 by 19 mm to about 36 by 23 mm in 18 carat gold, with LeCoultre movements, black Roman numerals often stretched towards the edge, blued steel hands, and no reference number: they are identified by English hallmarks and a Cartier London stock number, often repeated on the clasp. The largest size, whose dial is signed Cartier London, was made in batches of three to order, and fewer than six are known. The Crash is an asymmetric 18 carat yellow gold case about 43 mm long with a white dial signed London and a hand-wound Jaeger-LeCoultre movement; catalogues put the first series, from 1967, at fewer than a dozen or about 20 watches, with a second London run in the late 1980s whose size is not known. On the dials of the Tank Cintrée and elongated Tank models, London dropped the minute track and stretched the numerals; the hands became plain flame-blued sword hands in place of the Breguet pattern. One London Cintrée of 1929 with Arabic numerals, radium paint and cathedral hands is recorded as an isolated exception.

  • London hallmarks and a date letter inside the case back
  • JC punch and a Cartier London stock number, repeated on the clasp
  • dial signed London
  • stretched Roman numerals without a minute track
  • flame-blued sword hands

Cartier New York

The literature says little about New York watches. Pierre Cartier opened the house in 1909, with no royal connections to draw on, and moved it in 1917 to the mansion at 653 Fifth Avenue, which he acquired in exchange for a double string of natural pearls. Its workshops used mainly French craftsmen. Its clients included an American collector described as the house's most regular customer, and a drawing survives for a Tank Cintrée made at New York in 1935. A Maxi Oval from New York is pictured beside London pieces, so the oval was sold there too. At Christmas 1939 Pierre gave a President of the United States a Cartier coin watch made from a 1902 British gold crown, with a sapphire cabochon crown and the number 9308 stamped inside the lid; where it was made is not stated. Nothing in the literature sets out signatures, numbering or hallmarks for New York watches, and none of the other houses' rules should be assumed to apply.

Who made the cases and movements

Paris: movements came largely through the Paris maker Jaeger. The literature dates the start of that supply to 1903 in one account and to about 1905 in another, and describes the terms differently (see Where accounts differ). Jaeger and Cartier later set up the European Watch and Clock Company (EWC), whose name appears on movements; a head watchmaker there is credited with introducing Jaeger to Cartier, with the coin-watch method and with the D-shaped deployant buckle. LeCoultre built Jaeger's thin movements. When the contract with Jaeger ran out, Cartier in the 1930s also loosened its ties with Jaeger-LeCoultre, which stayed a supplier alongside Vacheron Constantin, Audemars Piguet and Piaget. In the 1970s the better-quality movements came largely from Vacheron Constantin and the more classical models from Ebel.

London: from 1966 London's own watches were cased by Wright & Davies, each by hand, and they made the first Crash cases from 1967; Cartier ran the workshop itself, but Jean-Jacques kept that hidden to prevent theft; the watch was then assembled and finished by the London head watchmaker. The London watches described have LeCoultre calibres, signed Jaeger-LeCoultre or LeCoultre Co. A different maker is named for the late-1980s Crashes. New York: the literature names no case or movement maker.

  • movement signed European Watch and Clock Co.
  • movement signed Jaeger-LeCoultre or LeCoultre Co.

Telling one house from another

The literature gives the clearest tests for London. English hallmarks inside the case back, with a date letter, are the main evidence that a watch was retailed through the Bond Street house; each letter covers two calendar years, so a dealer's single year is only a reading of it and the letter should be checked. The chart most often consulted is said to contain a misprint. A JC punch, a Cartier London stock number and sometimes London import marks are found inside the case back, and the stock number is often repeated on the gold deployant clasp, so a clasp that does not match the case number may be a later replacement. London dials may be signed London. Four-digit case numbers (such as 9526 and 9658) mark the first Crash series and five-digit numbers, some with a letter, the late-1980s run.

For Paris there is the classical dial of the original Tank Cintrée (serifed numerals and a railway minute track) and, much later, the word Paris under the brand name on Collection Privée dials. A Cintrée described as an anomaly, with Arabic numerals, has a case stamped EJ and numbered, a movement signed European Watch and Clock Co., and JC with a Glasgow import letter for 1936 inside the case; with the London import marks recorded on one London Baignoire, it shows that British marks may be import marks and do not by themselves show where a watch was made. Later editions can be mistaken for London pieces: the Paris edition of the Crash (limited to 400) is smaller, has Paris at 6 o'clock and a number on the back, and has a Cartier calibre. Marks vary with era, place of sale and later service, and a missing mark is a question rather than an answer.

  • London hallmark with date letter
  • JC punch
  • stock number matching the clasp
  • Paris printed under the signature
  • import marks inside the case back

The end of the three houses

Jacques Cartier and Louis Cartier died in 1941 and 1942; Pierre retired soon after the war and died in 1964. Their sons Jean-Jacques and Claude took over branches for some time, and after Pierre's death the surviving family sold the businesses. In 1972 a group of investors bought Cartier Paris and then the London and New York firms. By 1979 the three had been joined as Cartier Monde and the city distinction was no longer official. Even after 1979 the movement supply of the 1970s, from Vacheron Constantin and Ebel, continued until 1988, when Cartier bought Piaget and Baume & Mercier and could make movements in its own workshops. The 1960s are described by one account as a time of turmoil, with changes of ownership and a move towards the mass market; in the years that followed the firm kept a heritage line, the Collection Louis Cartier, beside a growing output of quartz watches. A Richemont subsidiary took the majority of the shares in 1993, Richemont reclaimed them in 1998, and it bought the remainder in 2012.

Must de Cartier

Must de Cartier was the name of the lower-priced range introduced in the 1970s: the first Must de Cartier watches appeared in 1977 by most accounts and in 1976 by others, and the Santos de Cartier with a two-tone bezel and screwed bracelet in 1978. The watches were gold-plated rather than solid gold, with quartz movements or standard ETA calibres, and production was increased to a scale not seen before. The head of Cartier from 1981 to 1998 is credited with defining the firm's modern luxury through the Must de Cartier line of objects, and with building the firm abroad from the positions of the three houses. These years are described as ones in which volume came before quality, after the small and artisanal production of the houses, and the change is given as the reason the mechanical collection of 1998 was needed.

  • gold-plated case
  • quartz or ETA movement

The Collection Privée Cartier Paris and after

Launched at the SIHH in 1998 and made until 2008, the Collection Privée Cartier Paris (CPCP) revived designs from the early houses, among them the Tank Cintrée, Santos-Dumont, Tortue, Tank Louis Cartier, Tank Asymétrique and Cloche, with the Pasha and Rotonde added later. One account dates the relaunch to 1997, the firm's hundred and fiftieth anniversary, and editions made before 1998, among them a Baignoire Allongée of 1991 and a Tank Asymétrique of 1996, are described in single accounts as Collection Privée pieces. All were in gold or platinum, many with cases slightly larger than the originals (the Collection Privée Cloche, dated 2007 by most accounts and 2006 by one, was about 15 per cent larger than the original of the early 1920s). Dials were of 18 carat gold, hand-decorated, nearly all with a central rosette and guilloché, and the word Paris under the signature, which one account says is absent only from the Cintrée. The movements were bought in, from Jaeger-LeCoultre, Piaget, Frédéric Piguet, Girard-Perregaux, Gérald Genta, Techniques Horlogères Appliquées and Renaud et Papi, then decorated in Cartier's workshops, including a double C and, on some calibres, a C-shaped index of blued steel; almost all had sapphire casebacks, platinum models excepted. Caseback engraving was small and in a traditional style, limited editions were numbered in their series, and the watches came in a larger leather box signed Collection Privée Cartier Paris with a certificate and manual. Some had a faceted crystal and a reissued vintage-style buckle, and casebacks could be engraved made in France.

Cartier ended the series because demand for in-house movements grew and because bought-in cases, movements and parts caused delays. It built a large manufacture at La Chaux-de-Fonds and a Geneva workshop during these years. The Fine Watch Making collection (2008 to 2018) followed, opening with a tourbillon on Cartier's own Geneva Seal calibre 9452 MC; most of its models had a large CARTIER engraved on the caseback with separate case and movement numbers.

  • Paris under the Cartier signature
  • rosette and guilloché on a gold dial
  • double C finish on the movement
  • sapphire caseback
  • Collection Privée Cartier Paris on the box
  • small engraved caseback with numbered limited editions

Chronology

1847
Louis-François Cartier takes over a Paris jewellery workshop and founds the firm.
1899
The Paris house moves to 13 rue de la Paix, still its home.
1902
Cartier London opens at 4 New Burlington Street, in the year of King Edward VII's coronation.
1904
Louis Cartier has a wristwatch designed for the aviator Alberto Santos-Dumont; the London house receives its first royal warrant in the same year.
1906
Jacques Cartier takes over the direction of the London house; another account places his taking charge in 1909, when Pierre left for New York.
1907
Pierre Cartier leaves for New York; one account has Jaeger signing a fifteen-year agreement to supply Cartier the same year.
1909
Cartier New York opens at 712 Fifth Avenue, and Cartier London moves to New Bond Street.
1911
The Santos-Dumont wristwatch is put on sale to the public.
1917
Cartier New York moves to 653 Fifth Avenue; Louis Cartier makes the first designs for the Tank.
1919
The Tank goes on sale, in a first series of six pieces; from then until 1960 the Paris house makes 1,803 Tanks.
1941
Jacques Cartier dies, in this year by two accounts and in 1942 by a third; Louis Cartier dies in 1942.
1964
Pierre Cartier dies; the remaining family then sell the three businesses.
1966
Cartier London begins to make its own watches, with cases from Wright & Davies; dates for the start of this vary between accounts.
1967
Cartier London launches the Crash.
1972
Investors led by a businessman buy Cartier Paris, and then the London and New York firms.
1977
The first Must de Cartier watches bring a lower-priced range into the catalogue; some accounts give 1976.
1979
The three houses are brought together as Cartier Monde, and the city names cease to matter officially.
1987
The earliest dated watches of a second London run of the Crash carry hallmarks for about 1987; the run continues to about 1990.
1988
Cartier buys Piaget and Baume & Mercier, giving it the means to make movements in its own workshops.
1998
The Collection Privée Cartier Paris is launched, at the SIHH; one account dates the relaunch to 1997.
2008
The Collection Privée Cartier Paris ends; the Fine Watch Making collection, with Cartier's own Geneva-made movements, replaces it.

Where accounts differ

  • When Cartier London began making its own watches. One account puts most of London's own watch production in the eight years from 1966 to 1974, and another says London imported all its watches until 1966. Another says London relied on Paris imports until Jean-Jacques Cartier added watchmakers in the 1960s, and dates his elongated Baignoire (the Allongée) to 1958. Another documents London Baignoires with hallmarks from about 1964. The year at which London stopped importing is therefore not settled.
  • Who founded Cartier London, and when Jacques took charge. The exhibition chronology in one account has London opened in 1902 under Pierre Cartier, with Jacques taking over the direction in 1906. Two others say Jacques set the London house up in 1902, while another says it was founded by both brothers, and two others say Pierre established it; one of those accounts has Jacques taking control only in 1909, when Pierre left for New York. The page in the first account also has Pierre leaving for New York in 1907 and opening the branch in 1909; two others give 1909 only.
  • When Jean-Jacques Cartier took over London. One account dates Jean-Jacques Cartier's taking over the London house from his father to the early 1960s. Two others have Jacques dying in 1941 and the sons taking over their fathers' branches, and one of those accounts calls Jacques the late father of Jean-Jacques in the 1960s. The literature does not settle when Jean-Jacques took charge.
  • The JC punch on London cases. One account reads the JC punch in London cases as the mark of Jacques Cartier on its page about the London Baignoire and as that of Jean-Jacques Cartier on its page about the London Crash. The literature does not settle whose initials the mark carries.
  • Start and terms of the supply from Jaeger. One account says Jaeger had been Cartier's main supplier since 1903 and signed a formal fifteen-year contract with exclusive rights to most of his output in 1907. Another places the arrangement at about 1905, describes it as an obligation on Cartier to take all of Jaeger's output with annual orders of at least 250,000 francs, and says many of the stories about Jaeger are folklore with little documentation.
  • Numerals on London dials: serifs or none. One account describes the London redesign as removing the minute track and the serifs from the numerals in one article, and in another describes a 1969 London Cintrée as having serifed Roman numerals that reach for the case edge. The articles agree that the London numerals are stretched and the minute track is gone; the serif detail is described both ways.
  • Death of Jacques Cartier. Two accounts give Jacques's death as 1941 and Louis's as 1942. The exhibition chronology in another gives 1942 for both.
  • How many Collection Privée watches were made. One account puts limited editions at 50, 100 or 150 pieces, other watches at about 200 to 500 in any configuration, and total output near 3,000 a year. Another gives limited editions of 100 and other models of no more than 200 to 250. The first account calls its figures estimates.
  • Start of the Collection Privée Cartier Paris. Most accounts date the Collection Privée Cartier Paris from 1998, several placing the launch at the SIHH of that year; one says it was relaunched in 1997, for the firm's hundred and fiftieth anniversary. Single accounts also describe a Baignoire Allongée edition of 1991 and a Tank Asymétrique edition of 1996 as Collection Privée pieces, while two others say the 1996 edition came before the formal launch.
  • Year of the Collection Privée Cloche. One account says the Cloche was recreated in 2006, about 15 per cent larger than the original, which it dates to 1922. Accounts of the Cloche date the Collection Privée edition of 100 to 2007, and most of them put the first Cloche wristwatch in 1921.
  • Date of the Baignoire. One account lists the Baignoire among the shapes the Paris workshop made from the Tank in the 1920s. Accounts of the Baignoire date the first oval design to 1912 and say the curved oval watch reached production in the late 1950s, most often 1958.
  • Year of the first Must de Cartier watches. Most accounts date the first Must de Cartier watches to 1977. One puts the Must de Cartier Tank on sale in 1976 and another gives 1976 to 1977.

In the records

Listings whose own title names a house. Most older watches are sold without one, so these are a floor, and a title naming Paris may be quoting a dial of any period.

House in the titleListingsWith no reference
Paris1,063630
London199187
New York4025